> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.cincinnaticpgedge.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Changing Brokers? Lead With Kindness.
- URL: https://www.cincinnaticpgedge.com/changing-brokers-lead-with-kindness/
- Published: 2026-11-09T10:10:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-09T10:09:59.000Z
- Description: Brands change brokers, and sometimes it’s the right call. Here’s how to do it with honesty and kindness, and why the person you’re letting go may be juggling more than you ever see.
- Author: Cincinnati CPG Edge
- Tags: Selling to Kroger

Brands change brokers. They always have, and they always will. Some move on to a new agency. Some decide to go direct. Anyone who has worked in brokerage for long has been on the receiving end of that call more times than they can count.

This post isn't here to tell you not to do it. Sometimes it's the right call. It's here to ask you to do it **with kindness**, and to be honest with yourself about *why* you're doing it. Those two things matter more than most brands realize.

## The Real Reasons Brands Make the Change

**You're consolidating to one national broker.** This is the cleanest reason of all. It's a business decision, not a judgment. Say so plainly, and everyone can part as friends.

**Your broker isn't performing at the level you need.** Fair. A good broker should either course correct or accept that they may not be the right fit for your business. Both are honest outcomes.

**You're not getting the attention you feel you deserve.** Notice the word *feel*. Feel is what you think, not how a broker works. Your broker partner may be doing a lot for you that you never see, because most of it happens quietly between your brand and the retailer. Before you decide attention is the problem, ask what's actually been done.

**You have a broker partner who simply isn't doing the job.** It happens, in brokerage and in every other industry. If that's the case, talk to the agency's leadership first. A good agency wants to know, and will often fix it before you have to leave.

**You need someone to blame.** This is the most common reason we see, and the least talked about. The brand isn't performing, someone has to answer for it, and the broker is the easiest name to put on the slide.

## Don't Build the Case by Breaking Them

This one happens far too often. A brand has already decided it wants a change, but instead of saying so, it piles on. Impossible deadlines. Requests stacked on requests. Weekly "urgent" reports nobody reads. Pressure turned up until something finally slips, and then the slip becomes the reason to leave.

Please don't do this. Setting someone up to fail so the paper trail says *they* didn't perform isn't a business strategy. It's bullying, and the people on the other end know exactly what's happening. So does the rest of the industry, eventually.

**If you feel you need a change, be up front about it.** No good ever came from making someone else the villain so the decision feels better. An honest conversation takes ten uncomfortable minutes. A manufactured case takes months, burns out a good person, hurts your business at the shelf while it plays out and follows your reputation long after the change is made.

## The Hardest One of All

The toughest change to watch is when a company's own struggles get handed to the broker to fix, and then the broker gets blamed when they can't.

Let's be clear about who owns what. Your broker partner works your product into the retailer's plan and should own the understanding of the retailer. **You own the brand.** Your formulation, your pricing, your packaging, your innovation pipeline, your supply and your marketing. Brand problems fall squarely on the brand's shoulders.

| *You hired a broker, not a full-time, all-in replacement to run your company.* |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |

Think about that one for a while, and let it sink in.

A broker is not responsible for running your company, and they aren't there to do your job for you. They can't fix a recipe the shopper has moved past, a product cost that's drifted out of line, a supply chain that can't keep the shelf full or a marketing plan that never showed up. Those decisions live inside your walls. Your broker carries your brand into the retailer and brings the retailer back to you. What you do with that is yours.

The brands that win with a broker treat it as a partnership. They lead their own business, and they let their broker be the expert at the retailer. When either side tries to do the other's job, or expects the other to do it for them, both lose.

And remember, your broker business manager is likely keeping 7 to 30 businesses afloat at the same time. Yours matters. It just isn't the only one.

If you're making a change to send a message inside your own company, we understand, and we know it happens. But do it with courtesy and respect. And please don't expect a ten-year download of everything going on and every reason behind your struggles on the way out the door. If you need that download now, it tells us the gap was never the broker's. It was the attention the brand wasn't paying all along.

## The Challengers Stopped Being Challengers

Here's the hard truth for a lot of established brands. The companies we used to call challenger brands aren't challengers anymore. They're fierce competitors.

They got there by paying attention. To the retailer, to the newer consumer, to the voids on the shelf. Meanwhile, many established brands were heads down on production, forecasts, grid sheets, trade shows, golf outings and time off. All good and necessary things. But while the brand that's been in stores forever kept doing what it always did, the shopper moved on.

Retailers are relentless about their own change, because they have to be to stay relevant. If you're not listening, you will lose. Period. Own that, and fix it. Just don't pin it on the person who was paying attention.

## Plastic Balls and Glass Balls

If you've never sat in a broker's chair, here's the best way we know to describe it.

The job is juggling. Lots of balls in the air at once, and the goal is to never let a single one hit the ground. Watch a juggler closely and you'll notice only one or two balls are being touched at any moment. The rest are in the air, trusting the rhythm. That's a broker.

Most of those balls are plastic. That's you, the brands. If one drops, it bounces. It hurts, it's not good, but it bounces. A good broker works every day to make sure none of them drop, no matter how many get added.

But mixed in with the plastic balls are a few made entirely of thin glass. Most manufacturers never see them. Frankly, plenty of brokerage leadership doesn't see them either.

| *The glass balls are our spouses, our children, our health and our families. They can never be dropped, no matter how many plastic ones get thrown into the mix.* |
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

If you understand that, good for you. If not, stop and read that line again, and think about what it represents in your own life.

## A Word to Brokerage Leadership, Too

This isn't only for manufacturers. When was the last time you said, "We need you to take this on. It should be easy and only take a little time each week"?

Every one of those asks lands on a week that's already 60-plus hours, with nights and weekends just to stay on top of it. Each new ball, large or small, makes the glass ones more vulnerable. Let that rest with you for a while.

And if your best people don't talk much about their wins, it's not because they don't care about recognition. It's because they don't have time to stop and tell you how well they did. Notice it anyway. Say it out loud.

## Thinking About Going Direct? Be Ready.

Some brands decide to go it alone. It can work, but go in with your eyes open. Your broker likely does more for you than you know, and most of it happens quietly. Things like:

- Chasing and disputing deductions before the clock runs out
- Item setup, cost changes and promotions entered correctly and on time
- Completing retailer forms and requests that arrive with no notice and are due right now
- Knowing every category review deadline before it sneaks up on you
- Reading the shopper data and turning it into a story the Category Manager trusts
- Fixing the store and supply issues you never even heard about
- Relationships built over years that open doors in a single phone call

When you go direct, you lose those experts. And you lose something else: someone to stand behind. You'll take every lump yourself, and you'll feel it in the red on your P&L. Going direct doesn't slow down the retailer's change, the consumer's change or your competitors' change. You'll be the stone in the water, and it's sink or swim.

If you're ready for that, build the team first, then make the move. Not the other way around.

| **How to Change Brokers With Kindness** **1\. Tell them yourself.** A call or a face-to-face, never just an email, and never let them hear it from the retailer first. **2\. Give the real reason.** Even if it's "we're consolidating" or "it's an internal decision." Honesty is a gift people can learn from. **3\. Honor the notice period.** Give a fair transition window and stay engaged through it. **4\. Pay what's owed, on time.** Settle commissions and open items promptly. Don't make them chase you on the way out. **5\. Ask for a transition plan, not a ten-year download.** Open deals, upcoming deadlines, key contacts. That's a fair ask. **6\. Don't badmouth them to the retailer.** Category Managers notice how you leave, and it says more about you than them. **7\. Say thank you, specifically.** Name something they did well. This industry is small, and you will cross paths again. |
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

And to our fellow brokers: when a change comes, take it with the same grace. Help the transition, protect the brand on the shelf and leave the door open. If it truly wasn't a fit, that's okay too. How we handle the exit is part of our reputation.

## If You Have a Good One, Cherish Them

Good help is hard to find in any industry. If you have a broker business manager who truly cares about your brand, treat them with respect, and respect their workload. Think of your own week, then multiply it by 15 or so.

If your broker is doing the job right, they have one of the hardest jobs in this industry. Many do it with grace and without much fanfare. A simple thank you goes further than you think.

The bottom line is this. Grocery as we know it is changing, and it will probably never return to what it was. That's not opinion, it's what we see every day. If we don't change with it, brands and brokers alike, it will roll us over.

So let's change together, and let's treat each other well while we do it. That's how we make us all better vendors.

Want more on the broker relationship? Read [**What Makes a Good Broker Partner**](https://cincinnaticpgedge.com/what-makes-a-good-broker-partner/?ref=cincinnaticpgedge.com), [**Stop Treating Your Broker Like a Necessary Evil**](https://cincinnaticpgedge.com/stop-treating-your-broker-like-a-necessary-evil/?ref=cincinnaticpgedge.com) and [**Is Your Brand Aging Out?**](https://cincinnaticpgedge.com/is-your-brand-aging-out/?ref=cincinnaticpgedge.com)

*Found this helpful? Pass it along to a colleague who works with Kroger. Great insights are better shared.*

| **Stay in the Kroger Know** Visit cincinnaticpgedge.com and subscribe for practical guidance on working with Kroger. [**Subscribe**](https://cincinnaticpgedge.com/?ref=cincinnaticpgedge.com#/portal/signup) |
| ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |

*From Cincinnati CPG Edge, keeping you in the Kroger know.*