Are You a Required Layer? Kroger Is Testing Every Cost in the Chain
At Investor Day, Kroger told a story about grapes. This month, the grapes are in the stores.
For the November 2026 season, Kroger sourced about 40% of its imported grapes directly from growers in Peru. No importer in the middle, no third party taking a margin to sit between the grower and the grocer. CFO David Kennerley described the goal plainly: Kroger wants to "take layers out of the chain."
It would be easy to read that as a produce story. It isn't. Grapes are simply the first place Kroger proved the idea works. The question underneath it applies to every company, team and service that touches an item between the field and the shelf, and that includes a lot of us reading this.
When we covered Kroger's Investor Day, we asked: are you a required layer, or just an added one? This post takes that question past the grape vine and into every corner of the supplier world.
|
THE LAYER TEST If you were removed from the chain tomorrow, what would be lost that could not easily be replaced? If you can answer that in one sentence, you are a required layer. If you need a paragraph, keep reading. |
Follow the Money Into the Cost of Goods
Every item on a Kroger shelf carries the cost of everyone who touched it. The ingredient supplier's margin. The co-packer's fee. The freight broker's spread. The 3PL's storage and handling. The broker's commission. The data subscriptions and the analysts who read them. The agency that designed the display. The software that manages the trade spend, and the firm that recovers the deductions.
Some of those costs sit inside the manufacturer's COGS. Some sit in the brand's cost to serve. All of them eventually show up in one place: the price the brand asks Kroger to pay, and the price the shopper sees on the tag.
That is why Kroger cares. Its new plan calls for a $5 billion investment in customer value by 2029, funded by roughly $4 billion in annual cost savings. CEO Greg Foran has said it plainly: take cost and complexity out, put the savings back into value. Kroger is doing that inside its own walls, cutting about 3,000 corporate roles over three years. Direct sourcing is the same idea pointed outward. And when a Category Manager pushes back on your cost increase, they are asking the same question about every layer baked into your price.
|
Our read: Kroger can't remove most of these layers itself. It doesn't need to. When it holds your cost flat, refuses an increase, or sources an Our Brands alternative direct, the pressure rolls back up the chain to every layer you pay. The layer test lands on your desk whether Kroger names you or not. |
What Kroger Has Already Shown Us
Direct sourcing is the clearest public example, and it is growing fast. Kroger wants to move from less than 1% of its purchases sourced direct to more than 10%. After grapes come citrus, shrimp and frozen vegetables. A South America hub is staffed, an Asia hub is being built for 2027, and the long-term goal is a fully owned import and distribution model.
Kroger has also said it is using better data to give its teams a clearer view of volume, demand, performance and alternatives when working with suppliers. That is the quiet part of the strategy. When a Category Manager can see exactly what your item does and what it would cost to replace, every layer in your price gets weighed against a real alternative.
Every Layer Gets the Same Test
Here is how the layer test looks for the people who make up this industry. Including ours.
Importers, distributors and consolidators. These are the layers Kroger is removing first. The ones who stay will be those who bring something Kroger can't build quickly: specialized cold chain, hard-to-reach supply, food safety expertise, or category know-how in places Kroger is not ready to go.
Brokers. A broker's commission comes out of the brand's margin, and that margin feeds the cost Kroger sees. A required broker earns it with retailer relationships, category review execution, KOMPASS preparation, promotional discipline and problems solved before the brand ever hears about them. A broker who mostly forwards emails and attends meetings is an added layer, and brands are starting to notice the difference. The good news for great brokers is that the bar rising makes great work easier to see.
CPG data and analytics teams. Syndicated data, 84.51 Stratum, dashboards, analysts and outside insight firms all cost real money. Required data work changes a decision: it wins a category review, saves an item from deletion, or stops a promotion that loses money. Added data work produces a beautiful report that nobody acts on. If your data spend can't point to the decisions it changed last year, it's a layer under review.
Co-packers and ingredient suppliers. As Kroger gets closer to growers and producers, it learns what things really cost at the source. Expect your customer, and your customer's customer, to know more about your margin than ever before. Efficiency, quality and reliability are the case for staying.
3PLs, freight brokers and warehouse partners. Kroger moves more freight than almost anyone, and it has little patience for freight-driven cost increases. A logistics partner who improves case fill, on-time delivery and cost per case is required. One who only adds a handoff and a markup is exposed.
Agencies, consultants and service vendors. Shopper marketing agencies, deduction recovery firms, trade promotion software, item data services. Each one should be able to show its return in dollars. If the return is "we've always used them," that is not an answer that will survive the next budget review.
And the brand itself. A brand is a layer too. If shoppers would happily buy an Our Brands version made from the same direct-sourced ingredient, the brand's markup is the layer being tested. The brands that pass are the ones shoppers seek out by name.
How to Prove You Are a Required Layer
Kroger is not trying to remove every partner in the chain. It is trying to remove cost that does not create value. That leaves room for anyone who can show they add more than they take. Wherever you sit, the proof looks similar:
1. Put a number on what you add. Sales you drove, cost you removed, deductions you recovered, items you saved, decisions you changed. "We help" is not a number. If you can't measure it, someone will measure it for you, and they may not be generous.
2. Know what replacing you would cost. Kroger is looking at alternatives. So is every brand. Understand your replacement cost better than the people paying you do, and make sure they understand it too.
3. Remove cost, don't just pass it along. The layers that survive are the ones that make the chain cheaper or simpler: fewer handoffs, fewer deductions, cleaner data, better freight. A partner who brings a cost reduction idea before being asked is speaking Kroger's language right now.
4. Bring demand, not just service. Layers that grow the business are harder to cut than layers that maintain it. Brokers who win new authorizations, data teams who find growth, brands that build households. Growth is the best defense there is.
5. Audit yourself before someone else does. Every brand should list every layer it pays between its raw materials and Kroger's dock, and ask the layer test of each one, including its own team. Every service partner should do the same with its own work. It is a much better conversation when you start it.
Every Layer Started for a Reason
It is worth saying plainly: the layers in this industry were not built by accident. Importers, distributors, brokers, co-packers, data providers and agencies all solved a real problem at some point. Many still do, and plenty of the work Kroger is taking in-house will prove harder than a slide makes it look.
But the bar has moved. Being in the chain used to be enough. Now every part of it, inside Kroger's walls and outside them, is being asked to prove what it adds. Kroger is asking that question of its own corporate teams right now. It would be naive to think the rest of us are exempt.
So take the layer test seriously. Write down the one sentence that explains what would be lost without you. Then go find the numbers that prove it. If you can't write that sentence yet, now is the time to build the work that earns it.
Found this helpful? Pass it along to a colleague who works with Kroger. Great insights are better shared.
|
Stay in the Kroger know Visit cincinnaticpgedge.com and subscribe to get every post in your inbox.
|
From Cincinnati CPG Edge, keeping you in the Kroger know.
|
KEEP CPG EDGE INDEPENDENT Enjoying CPG Edge? ☕ Cincinnati CPG Edge is independent and reader supported. No retailer, broker or brand pays for what gets written here. If this helped you work with Kroger a little smarter, you can buy me a coffee and help keep it going. |
Member discussion