Seasoned, Skilled, and Still Searching: Why CPG’s Most Experienced People Are Struggling to Land
You have probably noticed it too. Scroll LinkedIn for five minutes and the green "Open to Work" banners are everywhere. Not on first-year analysts. On people who ran national accounts, sat across the table from Category Managers for decades, built category reviews from scratch, and know how a deduction gets resolved before most of us know it exists.
So the question a lot of us are quietly asking: is it just me? Is it just the crowd I know? Or is something bigger going on in this industry?
It is not just you. And it is worth understanding why, because the answer is more complicated, and frankly more fair to the people looking, than "they didn't keep up."
The Numbers Back Up What You're Seeing
|
BY THE NUMBERS, 2026 9,677: job cuts announced by food companies in October, the most of any industry that month and the sector's highest month of the year (Challenger, Gray & Christmas). 39,370: food industry cuts announced through October, up 43% over last year. 3,000: corporate roles Kroger plans to eliminate over three years, roughly 37% of its corporate workforce. 3 months vs. 8+ months: the median vs. average time unemployed for workers ages 55 to 64 this September. Half land fairly quickly. The rest can be stuck a long time. |
That last number is the one that explains what you are feeling. On paper, older workers have a lower unemployment rate than younger ones. But the ones who do get caught in a search are staying caught far longer. Those are the people in your feed.
Five Reasons the Most Experienced People Are Struggling
1. There are fewer seats, not fewer good people
Everybody in the chain is removing layers at the same time. Retailers are flattening corporate teams. Manufacturers are cutting non-manufacturing roles and selling off brands. Brokers and distributors are consolidating. When the retailer, the manufacturer, and the agency in between all trim at once, a lot of very senior people land in the same pool, chasing the same handful of openings. That is a math problem, not a talent problem.
2. AI is landing on the middle of the work first
AI is not replacing judgment. It is replacing the hours that used to surround judgment: pulling the report, building the recap, formatting the deck, researching the deduction, summarizing the data. A lot of senior roles were built partly on "I'm the one who knows how to pull it and explain it." When a tool can pull it in seconds, leadership starts asking how many people they need around it.
To be fair, AI is not the whole story. Challenger's latest report shows market and economic conditions have overtaken AI as the top cited reason for job cuts in 2026. AI is an accelerant. A tough consumer, cost pressure, and slower growth are the fire.
3. The price tag is the first thing finance sees
Is the industry turning to the younger generation? Partly, but mostly for budget reasons, not because anyone decided wisdom is out of style. A senior salary is the first line item a CFO notices. And with AI tools, a junior hire can now produce output that looks like a senior person's work. It often isn't, but it looks close enough on a spreadsheet to win the budget conversation. That is a short-term trade a lot of companies will regret later.
4. The front door is often a robot
Many applications are screened by software before a human ever reads them. Age bias in automated screening is now being tested in court, including a nationwide collective action against a major HR platform covering applicants 40 and older. A 30-year resume, older system names, and early graduation dates can read as "expensive" or "dated" to a filter. You can be the most qualified person in the stack and never reach a person.
5. The job got renamed
Retail media. Precision marketing. Digital shelf. Shopper data platforms. eCommerce content. Much of this is work experienced people have been doing for years under older names. But if the job posting says "retail media analytics" and your resume says "promotional planning," the keyword match fails, even when you could run circles around the role.
So, Is It Because They Won't Embrace Change?
Honest answer: sometimes. We would be doing you a disservice to pretend otherwise. Some veterans still lead with "here's how we used to do it." Some wave off the data tools. Some are waiting for the market to come back to what it was. It won't. Grocery is not going back.
But for most of the people we know who are looking, that is not the story. They did not refuse change. The seats disappeared faster than anyone could learn the new names for the work on the job. Experience is not the problem. How that experience is packaged and presented is.
|
AI can draft a KOMPASS deck. It cannot tell you which Category Manager hates surprises, which division will push back on a cost increase, or why an item that looks fine in the data is about to get cut. That knowledge walks out the door with every experienced person who gets let go. |
If You're the One Looking
- Lead with outcomes, not years. "Grew a brand's Kroger distribution 40% across 12 divisions" beats "30 years of experience." Years invite a salary guess. Results invite a conversation.
- Show your tools out loud. If you use AI, shopper data platforms, or Power BI, say so and give a real example. Prove you are the person who adapted.
- Write for the robot, network for the human. Mirror the posting's language on your resume, then go around the front door. Most seasoned people land through someone who already knows their work.
- Consider fractional work. Small and emerging brands badly need Kroger know-how they cannot afford full-time. Consulting, project work, and part-time roles are real paths, and sometimes better ones.
- Teach. Mentor the younger people coming up. It keeps you visible, keeps you current, and reminds the industry what experience is actually worth.
- Don't confuse the market with your value. A long search says something about this moment. It says very little about what you know.
If You're the One Hiring
- The cheapest hire is not always the cheapest mistake. One missed category review or one botched cost increase conversation can cost more than a senior salary.
- Pair them up. A veteran plus a digital native is a stronger team than two of either.
- Check your filters. If your screening tool never sends you anyone over 50, that is not a talent shortage. That is a settings problem.
You Are Not Alone
If you are in a search right now, please hear this: it is not just you, and it is not just your circle. Some of the best people this industry has ever trained are looking at the same time, for reasons that have more to do with budgets, layers, and software than with talent. We would love to hear what you are seeing. Drop a comment, or pass this along to someone who could use the reminder.
Found this helpful? Pass it along to a colleague who works with Kroger. Great insights are better shared.
|
Stay in the Kroger know. Visit cincinnaticpgedge.com and subscribe to get every post in your inbox. Subscribe |
From Cincinnati CPG Edge, keeping you in the Kroger know.
Member discussion