Cincinnati CPG Edge is independent Kroger news and analysis for CPG brands.
No spin. No agenda. Just the insight to sell smarter and make all of us better vendors.

CPG Business 101, Lesson 15: How a category review is decided

CPG BUSINESS 101 |  LESSON 15 OF 15

How a category review is decided

A category review is the Category Manager deciding how to use a fixed amount of space to grow the whole category. Everything in this book feeds that decision. This lesson pulls it together: what gets weighed, how cutting an item really plays out, and what to bring.

1. What the Category Manager weighs
Sales and velocityHow much it sells, and how fast per store (Lesson 3)
Profit dollarsPenny profit × units, not just margin percent (Lesson 1)
TrendGrowing, flat or declining, and faster or slower than the category (Lesson 11)
UniquenessDoes it bring shoppers the set would lose, or would they buy the item next to it?
Space productivitySales and profit per foot or per facing
Shopper dataWho buys it, how loyal they are, whether they come back
SupportPromotions, coupons and marketing that drive the category
ReliabilityFill rate and in-stocks (a great item that is out of stock helps no one)
2. If the item is cut, where do its sales go?

When an item is cut, some of its shoppers switch to another item in the set. That is demand transfer. A me-too item transfers most of its sales, so cutting it costs the category little. A unique item transfers little, so cutting it costs real sales.

What cutting an item really costs the category

The share that transfers is the key number.

WORKED EXAMPLE

An item sells $200,000 a year. If 60% of its shoppers switch to other items, the category keeps $120,000 and loses $80,000 in sales.

If those shoppers switch to items with a higher margin, the profit loss is smaller still. That is why me-too items are the easiest to cut, and why proving your item is unique matters.

3. What to bring to the review
Category storyIs the category growing, and are you helping it? Category health check
Where you rankEvery item in the segment, red to green. Segment watch list
Your at-risk itemsThe facts and a plan for each. Category review risk check
Why you are differentThe shoppers and trips your items bring that others would not
A plan, with your money in itPromotions, coupons, new items and the investment behind them
One deckEverything above in one place. Category review prep kit

THE TAKEAWAY

Walk in knowing the Category Manager's numbers better than they expect you to. Lead with the category, show where you stand honestly, and bring a plan for the weak spots.

Common mistakes

WATCH FOR THESE

1. Arguing for every item, including the ones that are clearly weak.
2. Talking only about your brand, never the category.
3. Showing dollars without velocity, or growth without share.
4. Bringing a problem without a plan and funding behind it.

Quick check

Three questions. Tap an answer to see why.

1. An item sells $100,000 and 70% of its sales would move to other items if cut. What does the category lose in sales?

Only the share that does not transfer is lost: $100,000 × 30% = $30,000.

2. Which item is safest from a cut, all else equal?

Low transfer means the category would really lose those sales.

3. What should lead your category review story?

Category Managers are growing the category. Show how you help.

Build your review with the tools

WHAT SHOULD WE TEACH NEXT?

This book is built for all of us. Tell us what you wish someone had taught you: info@cincinnaticpgedge.com.

From Cincinnati CPG Edge, keeping you in the Kroger know.