Cincinnati CPG Edge is independent Kroger news and analysis for CPG brands.
No spin. No agenda. Just the insight to sell smarter and make all of us better vendors.

CPG Business 101, Lesson 14: Why the retailer needs your item

CPG BUSINESS 101 |  LESSON 14 OF 15

Why the retailer needs your item

Every new item asks the retailer to give up space that something else is already earning. The question a Category Manager is asking is not whether your item is good. It is what your item adds that the shelf does not already have, and why the retailer needs it.

1. Incremental, or just moving dollars around?

Your item's sales come from two places. Some are new to the category: new shoppers, new occasions, bigger baskets. The rest are taken from items already on the shelf, often including the item that gets cut to make room for yours. Only the first part grows the category. The second part just moves dollars from one tag to another.

What your item really adds to the category

Your projected sales, split into new dollars and borrowed dollars.

WORKED EXAMPLE

Your item is projected to sell $250,000 a year, but only 25% of that is new to the category. The other $187,500 comes from items shoppers were already buying.

To make room, the retailer cuts an item selling $150,000. Most of its shoppers switch to something else, but $60,000 walks away. Net gain to the category: about $2,500. On your report the launch looks like $250,000. To the Category Manager it is $250,000 moved around the shelf, plus slotting, set changes and risk.

2. Why the freezer is not all chocolate and vanilla

Picture the ice cream aisle if every brand got in with its best seller. It would be chocolate and vanilla from one end of the freezer to the other. Each one would be a strong item, and the aisle would still fail, because shoppers come to a category for choice: flavors, sizes, diets, price points and occasions.

That is why your best-selling item may be the one the shelf needs least. If the set already has five great chocolates, a sixth adds very little, no matter how well it sells for you somewhere else. The Category Manager is building the whole aisle, not ranking your line.

IT IS NOT A JUDGMENT ON YOUR ITEM

They want your meatballs, not your best-selling patty.

You sell a frozen meatless line, and your patty is the hero. You lead with it. The Category Manager asks about your sausage links and meatballs instead.

That is not a knock on the patty. The retailer is already selling every meatless patty its shoppers want. Adding yours would mostly shift dollars from one patty to another. Links and meatballs reach shoppers and meals the set does not cover today, so they grow the section.

When the Category Manager picks a different item from your line, that is a yes. Take it, make it win, and earn the next one.

3. The questions every Category Manager is asking
Is it a me-too?Same product, same benefit, similar price as something already on the shelf. Me-toos rarely earn space.
Does it bring new shoppers?New households, new occasions, new trips. Or is it the same shoppers switching from one item to another?
Does it fill a gap?A flavor, size, form, diet, occasion or price tier the set is missing today.
Is it new, or riding a real trend?True innovation, an added function, or a need that is growing in the category, backed by data.
Is there a store brand already?If the retailer’s own brand covers the basic version, a national brand has to offer something the copy does not.
Does it make money?Margin and profit dollars that hold up against the item it would replace (Lesson 1).
Will you support it?A funded launch plan to drive trial: promotion, digital, sampling, marketing (Lessons 6 and 7).
Why does the retailer need you?Can you finish this sentence: “Shoppers will come to this aisle for ___, and today they cannot find it”?
4. Me-too vs incremental
Me-too itemIncremental item
Who buys itShoppers already buying the categoryNew households, or current shoppers on a new occasion
Where its sales come fromMostly from items already on the shelfMostly new to the category
What the retailer gainsLittle, plus slotting work and a set changeCategory growth, traffic and a reason to visit
How it is pitched“It is our best seller”“Here is the gap in your set, and the shoppers it will bring”
What happens at the next reviewFirst in line to be cutEarns its space, and room for more
5. Pitch the gap, not the item

Start with the category, not your brand. Show where the set is growing, who it is missing, and what shoppers are buying elsewhere that they cannot find here. Then show how your item fills that gap, with data: household and trend growth, sales at other retailers, and how much of your volume you expect to be new.

Be honest about overlap. If your item will take sales from something on the shelf, say so, and say which item you would replace, including one of your own if it is weaker. Category Managers trust the supplier who has already done the math on their behalf.

THE TAKEAWAY

The retailer does not need another good item. It needs a reason the category will grow. Know what your item adds that the shelf does not already have, and lead with that. If the honest answer is “not much,” find the item in your line that does.

Common mistakes

WATCH FOR THESE

1. Leading with “it is our best seller” instead of what the shelf is missing.
2. Pitching an item that copies one already on the shelf, including the store brand.
3. Counting all of your projected sales as new to the category.
4. Pushing back when the Category Manager prefers a different item from your line.

Quick check

Three questions. Tap an answer to see why.

1. Your new item will sell $200,000 a year, and 80% of that will come from items already on the shelf. How much is new to the category?

Only the incremental part grows the category: $200,000 × 20% = $40,000.

2. Which item is most likely to earn a spot?

Category Managers add items that grow the category. A gap filled beats a duplicate, however well it sells.

3. The Category Manager wants your meatballs, not your best-selling patty. What does that usually mean?

The set already covers patties. Meatballs reach meals and shoppers it does not, so they add more to the section.

Try it with your own numbers

WHAT SHOULD WE TEACH NEXT?

This book is built for all of us. Tell us what you wish someone had taught you: info@cincinnaticpgedge.com.

From Cincinnati CPG Edge, keeping you in the Kroger know.